吉首大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2013, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (1): 85-91.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1007-4074.2013.01.014

• 政治学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

正义与民主之争——基于古典政治哲学的研究

  

  1. (西北农林科技大学 人文学院,陕西 杨凌712100)
  • 出版日期:2013-01-15 发布日期:2013-01-21
  • 作者简介:樊凡,男,博士,西北农林科技大学人文学院讲师。
  • 基金资助:

    教育部人文社会科学研究基金青年项目(11YJC810031);国家社会科学基金项目(12CZZ005)

Conflict between Justice and Democracy:A Research Based on Classical Political Philosophy

  1. (School of Humanities,Northwest A&F University,Yangling 712100,Shanxi China)
  • Online:2013-01-15 Published:2013-01-21

摘要:在今日政治哲学研究中,民主与正义之间的否定性关系似乎被遮蔽了。但在古典政治哲学看来,民主与正义之间存在着诸多的对立,这主要表现在:民主不仅不是构建、强化正义的途径,而且,民主往往扮演着削弱、祛除正义的角色——从分配正义的角度讲,正义要求按照人与人之间的自然差别以及待分配之物所承载的意义来分配具有社会意义的资源,而民主则以平等为导向对其进行分配;从交换正义的角度讲,正义与民主的对立表现为市场与政治的对立,正义要求人与人之间的具有非政治性特征的交易活动应遵循自愿对等原则,这与作为政治活动方式的民主有着本质区别;从矫正正义的角度讲,正义与民主的对立表现为法律权力与人民主权的对立,正义需要的是法治而非民主。

关键词: 正义, 民主, 古典政治哲学

Abstract: During the recent research about political philosophy the negative relationships between democracy and justice have seemed to be enclosed.But there are a lot of oppositions between democracy and justice,which are mainly based on the followings:democracy is not only the approach to constructing and reinforcing justice in classical political philosophy,but also plays the role of weakening and eliminating justice.From the perspective of distributive justice,the opposition between justice and democracy lies in the opposition between being naturally right and being artificially equal.Justice demands that distributing resources with social meaning should be based on interpersonal natural ranking and the meaning that  carried by resources.While democracy requires the distribution should be equally.And from the perspective of commutative justice,the opposition between justice and democracy lies in the opposition of the market and politics.And from the perspective of commutative justice,justice refers to that people participate in non-public activities under the principle of being voluntary and equal.And from the perspective of corrective justice,the opposition between justice and democracy lies in the opposition between judicial powers and popular sovereignty.What justice requires is the rule of law but not democracy.

Key words: justice;democracy, classical political philosophy

版权所有 © 2021《吉首大学学报(社会科学版)》编辑部
技术支持:北京玛格泰克科技发展有限公司
公众号 电子书橱 超星期刊 手机浏览 在线QQ