Research on the Legal Force of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)Result

doi:10.13438/j.cnki.jdxb.2016.04.004

Abstract

Abstract:

Environmental impact assessment is an important manifestation of the precautionary principle in environmental law,and the result of EIA determines whether EIA actually plays a role in preventing environmental pollution and ecological damage.There are two main system designs,e.g.the entity veto effect and “purely procedural” binding effect.EIA result in our country has an entity veto effect,which determines whether the project development should be approved.However,the entity veto effect is often under question due to lack of actual effect in practice.Considering this,it is not acceptable to neglect the legal tradition of giving importance to entity and ignoring procedure in order to pursue rapid economic growth,nor is it wise to simply pursue pure procedure.

Key words: EIA result, procedure, legal force

RUAN Lijuan,WU Tianyi. Research on the Legal Force of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)Result[J]. Journal of Jishou University（Social Sciences）, DOI: 10.13438/j.cnki.jdxb.2016.04.004.

References

[1] 李艳芳.关于环境影响评价制度建设的思考[J].南京社会科学，2000(7).
[2] Lynton K.Caldwell.Environmental Policy as A Political Problem[J].Policy Studies Review，1993,12(3).
[3] 李建良.环境行政程序的法制与实务——以“环境影响评估法”为中心[J].月旦法学，2004(1).
[4] 傅玲静.由行政程序法之适用论我国环境影响评估审查之法制[J].中原财经法学，2009(22).
[5] 叶俊荣，张文贞.环境影响评估制度问题之探讨[R].台湾：行政院研究发展考核委员会,2010.
[6] 汪劲.中外环境影响评价制度比较研究[M].北京：北京大学出版社，2006.
[7] 候蓓丽.未做环评者搞你没商量[J].绿色视野，2007(7).
[8] 沈希贤，等.182人诉北京市规划委员会颁发建设工程规划许可证纠纷案[EB/OL].（2014-10-17）[2016-03-05].http://www.110.com/panli/panli_61452.html.
[9] 汪劲.环境正义：丧钟为谁而鸣——美国联邦法院环境诉讼经典判例选[M].北京：北京大学出版社，2006.
[10] 康文尚.试析美国环境影响评估制度的行政监督[J].中研院法学期刊，2012（11）.
[11] 刘如慧.从环境影响评估及团体诉讼看德国环境法的欧洲化冲击[J].欧美研究季刊，2011（2）.
[12] 刘宗德.环境行政之实效性确保[D].台北：国立政治大学法律学系，2000.
[13] 王迺宇.永续发展下之无牙老虎？——我国环境影响评估法的检讨[J].静宜人文社会学报，2006（1）.
[14] 吕雅雯，黄锦堂，于幼华.永续发展理念下的环境影响评估制度[J].环境工程会刊,1999(2).
[15] Lynton K.Caldwell.Understanding Impact Analysis:Technical Process,Administrative Reform,Policy Principle[M]//Policy Through Impact Assessment：Institutionalized Analysis As A Policy Strategy 7，9(Robert V.Bartlett ed.,1989).
[16] William A. Tilleman.Public Participation in the Environmental Impact Assessment Process:a Comparative Study of Impact Assessment in Canada，the United States and the European Community[J].Columbia Journal of Transnational Law,1995,33(2).
[17] 杨兴.提高环境影响评价制度法律实效的构想[J].中南大学学报（社会科学版）,2013(5).
[18] Heather N.Stevenson. Environmental Impact Assessment Laws in the Ninities:Can the United States and Mexico Learn from Each Other？[J].U.Rich.L.Rev，1998.