公共管理学科对繁文缛节研究的综述

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1007-4074.2012.06.013

摘要/Abstract

摘要：繁文缛节指对组织绩效有害的冗余行政规则、规章和程序。繁文缛节是一种“官僚病”，对公共组织绩效危害较大，并在西方公共管理研究领域得到了广泛关注。本文对国际公共管理领域繁文缛节的研究进展进行了综述，概述了繁文缛节的概念与测量、影响因素与作用后果，并明确了未来繁文缛节研究的重要方向与议程。

关键词： 繁文缛节, 公共组织, 官僚制, 政府绩效

Abstract: Red tape refers to the rules,regulations,and procedures that are harmful to organizational performance.Asthe bureaucratic pathology,red tape is harmful to public organization and has been studied extensively in the Western Public Administration field.The construction,measurement,antecedents,and consequences of red tape are reviewed in the paper,in which we outline the future research avenues and agenda.

Key words: Red Tape, public organization, bureaucracy, government performance

马亮, 孙晓燕. 公共管理学科对繁文缛节研究的综述[J]. 吉首大学学报（社会科学版）, 2012, 33(6): 87-95.

MA Liang, SUN Xiao-Yan. On Red Tape in the Public Administration Field:A Literature Review[J]. Journal of Jishou University（Social Sciences）, 2012, 33(6): 87-95.

参考文献

[1] OECD.Cutting Red Tape:Comparing Administrative Burdens across Countries[M].Paris:OECD,2007.

[2] BOZEMAN B.Bureaucracy and Red Tape[M].Upper Saddle River,NJ:Prentice-Hall,2000.

[3] BOZEMAN B,Feeney MK.Rules and Red Tape:A Prism for Public Administration Theory and Research[M].New York:ME Sharpe,2011.

[4] BUCHANAN B.Red-tape and the service ethic:Some unexpected differences between public and private managers[J].Administration & Society,1975,6(4).

[5] KAUFMAN H.Red Tape:Its Origins,Uses,and Abuses[M].Washington,DC:Brookings Institution,1977.

[6] GOODSELL C T.Red Tape and a Theory of Bureaucratic Rules[J].Public Administration Review,2000,60(4).

[7] BOZEMAN B.A Theory of Government “Red Tape”[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,1993,3(3).

[8] OSBORNE D,GAEBLER T.Reinventing Government:How the Entrepreneurial Spirit is Transforming the Public Sector[M].Reading,Mass.:Addison-Wesley,1992.

[9] GORE A.From Red Tape to Results:Creating a Government That Works Better & Costs Less[M].Washington,DC:US Government Printing Office,1993.

[10] ROSENFELD R A.An expansion and application of Kaufman's model of red tape:The case of community development block grants[J].Western Political Quarterly,1984,37(4).

[11] BALDWIN J N.Perceptions of Public versus Private Sector Personnel and Informal Red Tape:Their Impact on Motivation[J].The American Review of Public Administration,1990,20(1).

[12] BOZEMAN B,SCOTT P G.Bureaucratic Red Tape and Formalization:Untangling Conceptual Knots[J].American Review of Public Administration,1996,26(1).

[13] BOZEMAN B,REED P N,SCOTT P G.Red Tape and Task Delays in Public and Private Organizations[J].Administration & Society,1992,24(3).

[14] PANDEY S K,SCOTT P G.Red Tape:A Review and Assessment of Concepts and Measures[J].J Public Adm Res Theory,2002,12(4).

[15] PANDEY S K,GARNETT J L.Exploring Public Sector Communication Performance:Testing a Model and Drawing Implications[J].Public Administration Review,2006,66(1).

[16] COURSEY D H,PANDEY S K.Content Domain,Measurement,and Validity of the Red Tape Concept:A Second-Order Confirmatory Factor Analysis[J].The American Review of Public Administration,2007,37(3).

[17] PANDEY S K,MARLOWE J.Taking Stock of Survey-based Measures of Bureaucratic Red Tape:Mere Perceptions or More than Meets the Eye?[C].the 10th Public Management Research Association Conference.John Glenn School of Public Affairs,Ohio State University,Columbus,Ohio,2009.

[18] WALKER R M,BREWER G A.An Organizational Echelon Analysis of the Determinants of Red Tape in Public Organizations[J].Public Administration Review,2008,68(6).

[19] FEENEY M K,BOZEMAN B.Stakeholder Red Tape:Comparing Perceptions of Public Managers and Their Private Consultants[J].Public Administration Review,2009,69(4).

[20] PANDEY S K,BRETSCHNEIDER S I.The Impact of Red Tape's Administrative Delay on Public Organizations' Interest in New Information Technologies[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,1997,7(1).

[21] RAINEY H G,PANDEY S,BOZEMAN B.Public and Private Managers' Perceptions of Red Tape[J].Public Administration Review,1995,55(6).

[22] BOZEMAN B,DEHART-DAVIS L.Red Tape and Clean Air:Title V Air Pollution Permitting Implementation as a Test Bed for Theory Development[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,1999,9(1).

[23] SCOTT P G,PANDEY S K.The influence of red tape on bureaucratic behavior:An experimental simulation[J].Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,2000,19(4).

[24] KAUFMANN W,FEENEY M K.Objective Formalization,Perceived Formalization and Perceived Red Tape[J].Public Management Review,2012.

[25] FEENEY M K.Organizational Red Tape:A Measurement Experiment[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2012,22(3).

[26] BRETSCHNEIDER S,CHEN X-H,WU L,et al.A new approach to measuring red tape from survey data:Controlling for perceptions of formalization[C].Annual Conference of the International Public Management Network(IPMN) 2012.Hawaii,2012.

[27] DEHART-DAVIS L,PANDEY S K.Red tape and public employees:Does perceived rule dysfunction alienate managers?[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2005,15(1).

[28] MOYNIHAN D P,PANDEY S K.The Role of Organizations in Fostering Public Service Motivation[J].Public Administration Review,2007,67(1).

[29] MOON M J,BRETSCHNEIDER S.Does the Perception of Red Tape Constrain IT Innovativeness in Organizations? Unexpected Results from a Simultaneous Equation Model and Implications[J].J Public Adm Res Theory,2002,12(2).

[30] WRIGHT B E,PANDEY S K.Transformational Leadership in the Public Sector:Does Structure Matter?[J].J Public Adm Res Theory,2010,20(1).

[31] PANDEY S K,COURSEY D H,MOYNIHAN D P.Organizational Effectiveness and Bureaucratic Red Tape:A Multimethod Study[J].Public Performance & Management Review,2007,30(3).

[32] WALKER R M,BREWER G A.Can Management Strategy Minimize the Impact of Red Tape on Organizational Performance?[J].Administration Society,2009,41(4).

[33] BREWER G A,WALKER R M.The Impact of Red Tape on Governmental Performance:An Empirical Analysis[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2010,20(1).

[34] YACKEE J W,YACKEE S W.Administrative Procedures and Bureaucratic Performance:Is Federal Rule-making “Ossified”?[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2010,20(2).

[35] 董皓.自由裁量权、繁文缛节和政府绩效：面向中国地方政府的探索性研究[D].西安:西安交通大学,2007.

[36] MOYNIHAN D P,HERD P.Red Tape and Democracy:How Rules Affect Citizenship Rights[J].American Review of Public Administration,2010(6).

[37] GURIEV S.Red tape and corruption[J].Journal of Development Economics,2004,73(2).

[38] SCOTT P G.Examining red tape in public and private organizations:a further look at the role of individual perceptions and attributes[J].The Social Science Journal,2002,39(3).

[39] RAINEY H G,BOZEMAN B.Comparing Public and Private Organizations:Empirical Research and the Power of the A Priori[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory:J-PART,2000,10(2).

[40] BOZEMAN B,RAINEY H G.Organizational Rules and the “Bureaucratic Personality”[J].American Journal of Political Science,1998,42(1).

[41] SCOTT P G,PANDEY S K.Red Tape and Public Service Motivation:Findings from a National Survey of Managers in State Health and Human Services Agencies[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,2005,25(2).

[42] CHEN G,WILLIAMS D W.How Political Support Influences Red Tape through Developmental Culture[J].Policy Studies Journal,2007,35(3).

[43] TORENVLIED R,AKKERMAN A.Effects of Managers’ Work Motivation and Networking Activity on Their Reported Levels of External Red Tape[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2012,22(3).

[44] PONOMARIOV B L,BOARDMAN P C.Organizational Pathology Compared to What? Impacts of Job Characteristics and Career Trajectory on Perceptions of Organizational Red Tape[J].Public Administration Review,2011,71(4).

[45] DAVIS R S.Union Commitment and Stakeholder Red Tape:How Union Values Shape Perceptions of Organizational Rules[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,2012.

[46] DEHART-DAVIS L.Green Tape:A Theory of Effective Organizational Rules[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2009,19(2).

[47] Eggers WD.Government 2.0:Using Technology to Improve Education,Cut Red Tape,Reduce Gridlock,and Enhance Democracy[M].Lanham:Rowman & Littlefield Publishers,Inc.,2007.

[48] WELCH E W,PANDEY S K.E-Government and Bureaucracy:Toward a Better Understanding of Intranet Implementation and Its Effect on Red Tape[J].Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2007,17(3).

[49] PELED A.Do Computers Cut Red Tape?[J].The American Review of Public Administration,2001,31(4).

[50] 林静美.全面电子档案管理制度对组织之冲击——资讯科技同化与繁文缛节[J].政策研究学报,2006(6).

[51] PANDEY S K,WELCH E W.Beyond Stereotypes:A Multistage Model of Managerial Perceptions of Red Tape[J].Administration Society,2005,37(5).

[52] WALKER R M,BREWER G A.Can public managers reduce red tape? The role of internal management in overcoming external constraints[J].Policy & Politics,2009,37(2).

[53] 马亮.作为一种官僚病的繁文缛节：评《官僚制与繁文缛节》 [J].公共行政评论,2010,3(1).

[54] HOFSTEDE G.Culture's Consequences:Comparing Values,Behaviors,Institutions and Organizations Across Nations[M].Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage Publications,2001.

[55] BREWER G A,WALKER R M.Explaining Variations in Perceptions of Red Tape:A Professionalism-Marketization Model[J].Public Administration,2010,88(2).

[56] BUEN J.Red Tape or Green Guanxi? A Tentative Theoretical Framework for Understanding Chinese Environmental Technology Policy[C].Nordic Association ofChina Studies Conference.Stockholm/Tallinn,1999.