同意的涵义、性质及其类别

doi:10.13438/j.cnki.jdxb.2019.05.003

摘要/Abstract

摘要：在伦理学视野下，最一般意义的同意是同意者基于自己的意志自由，以某种作为或不作为的形式，对被同意者提出的要求、建议或意见等给予肯定或否定的意思表示。除了一般的同意概念之外，还有次一级的概念如明示同意与默示同意、假设同意与推定同意以及拒绝同意、撤销同意和非同意等关联概念也应当引起人们的注意。次一级的同意概念，应当在理解一般意义的同意概念基础上依据其所在特殊情境予以具体理解。

关键词： 同意, 政治, 哲学, 伦理

Abstract: From the perspective of ethics,the most general sense of consent is that the consenting person,based on his own will,in some form of act or omission,gives a positive or negative expression of intention to the request,suggestion or opinion put forward by the consentee.In addition to the general concept of consent,there are concepts at the secondary level,such as express consent,implied consent,hypothetical consent and presumed consent.Some relevant concepts,such as refusal to consent,withdraw of consent and disconsent should also arouse people's attention.The concept of consent at the second level should be specifically understood according to its special situation on the basis of understanding the concept of consent in the general sense.

Key words: consent, politics, philosophy, ethics

吕耀怀. 同意的涵义、性质及其类别[J]. 吉首大学学报（社会科学版）, DOI: 10.13438/j.cnki.jdxb.2019.05.003.

LV Yaohuai. The Meaning,Nature and Category of Consent[J]. Journal of Jishou University（Social Sciences）, DOI: 10.13438/j.cnki.jdxb.2019.05.003.

参考文献

[1] PARKER M H,KOMESAROFF P A.Ethical Aspects of Consent[J].Issues,2009,86(86):24-28. [2] CASSINELLI C W.The "Consent" of the Governed[J].The Western Political Quarterly,1959,12(2):391-409. [3] KLEINIG J.The Ethics of Consent[J].Canadian Journal of Philosophy,1982,12(Supp 1):91-118. [4] BERNARD B R.On Some Criticisms of Consent Theory[J].Journal of Social Philosophy,2010,24(1):81-102. [5] HYAMS K D.When Consent Doesn't Work:A Rights-Based Case for Limits to Consent's Capacity to Legitimise[J].Journal of Moral Philosophy,2011,8(1):110-138. [6] ALEXANDER LARRY.The Ontology of Consent[J].Analytic Philosophy,2014,55(1):102-113. [7] KLEINIG Y.The Nature of Consent[M]//MILL F,WERTHEIMER A.The Ethics of Consent.Oxford:Ox-ford University Press,2010:3-24. [8] O'SHEA T.Green Paper Report:Consent in History,Theory and Practice[R/OL].Essex Autonomy Project:https://autonomy.essex.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Consent-GPR-June-2012.pdf. [9] JOHNSTON D.A History of Consent in Western Thought[M]//MILL F，WERTHEIMER A.The Ethics of Consent.Oxford:Ox-ford University Press,2010:25-53. [10] HURD H M.The Moral Magic of Consent[J].Legal Theory,1996,2(2):121. [11] SIMMONS A J.Consent Theory for Libertarians[J].Social Philosophy and Policy,2005,22(1):330-356. [12] HARRIS E A.From Social Contract to Hypothetical Agreement:Consent and the Obligation to Obey the Law[J].Colum.l.rev,1992,92(3):651-683. [13] SIMMONS A J.Tacit Consent and Political Obligation[J].Philosophy & Public Affairs,1976,5(3):274-291. [14] ALBERT W.Consent[J].Political Studies，1978，26(1):65-77. [15] MALOBERTI N.The Fallacy of Consent[J].Journal of Value Inquiry,2010,44(4):469-476. [16] VEATCH R M.Implied,Presumed and Waived Consent:The Relative Moral Wrongs of Under-and Over-Informing[J].The American Journal of Bioethics,2007,7(12):39-41. [17] KANN M E.The Dialectic of Consent Theory[J].The Journal of Politics,1978,40(2):23. [18] MANSON N C.Normative Consent Is Not Consent[J].Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics,2013,22(1):33-44. [19] STARK C A.Hypothetical Consent and Justification[J].Journal of Philosophy,2000,97(6):313-334. [20] SLOTE M A.Desert,Consent,and Justice[J].Philosophy & Public Affairs,1973,2(4):323-347. [21] ARTHUR K.Hypothetical Consent[M]//MILL F，WERTHEIMER A.The Ethics of Consent.Oxford:Ox-ford University Press,2010:131-161. [22] GERVER M.Consent for Data on Consent[J].Ethical Theory & Moral Practice,2014,18(4):1-18. [23] HARTOGH G D.Can Consent be Presumed?[J].Journal of Applied Philosophy,2011,28(3):295-307. [24] DAVIS J K.Precedent Autonomy and Subsequent Consent[J].Ethical Theory and Moral Practice,2004,7(3):267-291. [25] DOUGHERTY T.Fickle Consent[J].Philosophical Studies,2014,167(1):25-40. [26] PATEMAN C.Women and Consent[J].Political Theory,1980,8(2):149-168. [27] BELL T W.Graduated Consent Theory,Explained and Applied[J].SSRN Electronic Journal,2009（3）：3-33.