家族企业人情化氛围对辱虐管理效应的影响机制——基于多案例的探索研究

doi:10.13438/j.cnki.jdxb.2017.05.008

摘要/Abstract

摘要：运用案例研究方法，选取3家明显具有辱虐管理风格的家族企业为案例分析对象，通过对3家企业人情化组织氛围的挖掘和分析，探索出其对辱虐管理作用结果的调节效应，从而加深了对组织氛围作为一种情境因素影响辱虐管理作用结果的内在机制的认识。经过数据收集、编码和分析，归纳出辱虐管理、家族企业氛围与员工情绪反应、心理感知和工作态度等变量之间的逻辑关系，并据此提出6个研究命题，研究发现：（1）案例企业表现出具有身心自由、人文关怀、团结一致特征的人情化组织氛围；（2）这种人情化组织氛围能够弱化辱虐管理对员工工作疏离感的正向影响，并弱化辱虐管理对员工工作投入度的负向影响；（3）人情化氛围对辱虐管理作用结果产生以上调节性影响的机制在于，这一组织氛围使员工产生了对上级领导行为的同理心和对组织的认同感，从而弱化了辱虐管理对员工心理状态和工作态度的破坏性作用。

关键词： 家族企业, 辱虐管理, 人情化氛围, 同理心, 认同感

Abstract: Based on the case study method，we select 3 family firms which show significant abusive supervision in the company as our research objects.Through the mining and analyzing process to the humanistic atmosphere of these three companies，we try to figure out the internal mechanism of its moderating effect on the relationship between abusive supervision and employees' reactions which may deepen our understanding of the mechanism of how organizational atmosphere，as a situational factor，influences the effects of abusive supervision.Within the process of data collection，encoding and analyzing，we summarized the logical relationship among these variables including abusive supervision，humanistic atmosphere of family business,emotional,perceptual and attitudinal reaction of employees.We accordingly put forward 6 propositions of the influencing mechanism framework of humanistic atmosphere.It is found that the freedom of mind and body，humanistic care and solidarity in family business create a humanistic atmosphere,that this kind of atmosphere could weaken the positive effect of abusive supervision on employees' work alienation and also weaken the negative effect of abusive supervision on employees' job engagement,and that the internal mechanism of the influence of humanistic atmosphere has on the effect of abusive supervision lies in employees' empathy for leaders' abusive behavior and identification for organization this kind of atmosphere brought about,which may weaken the destructive effects of abusive supervision on employees' psychological perception and work attitude.

Key words: family business, abusive supervision, humanistic atmosphere, empathy, identification

李朋波，孙雨晴. 家族企业人情化氛围对辱虐管理效应的影响机制——基于多案例的探索研究[J]. 吉首大学学报（社会科学版）, DOI: 10.13438/j.cnki.jdxb.2017.05.008.

LI Pengbo,SUN Yuqing. The Mechanism of How the Humanistic Atmosphere of Family Business Influences the Effects of Abusive Supervision——An Exploratory Research Based on the Multi-Case Study[J]. Journal of Jishou University（Social Sciences）, DOI: 10.13438/j.cnki.jdxb.2017.05.008.

参考文献

[1] Tepper B J.Consequences of abusive supervision[J].Academy of Management Journal，2000，43(2). [2] Thau S，Bennett R J，Mitchell M S，et al.How management style moderates the relationship between abusive supervision and workplace deviance：An uncertainty management theory perspective[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes，2009，108(1). [3] Conger J A.The dark side of leadership[J].Organizational Dynamics，1990，19(2). [4] Lee S，Yun S，Srivastava A.Evidence for a curvilinear relationship between abusive supervision and creativity in South Korea[J].The Leadership Quarterly，2013，24(5). [5] 严丹.辱虐管理一定会导致员工沉默吗?——以领导成员交换作为调节变量的实证研究[J].财经论丛，2012(6). [6] Wang W，Mao J，Wu W，et al.Abusive supervision and workplace deviance：The mediating role of interactional justice and the moderating role of power distance[J].Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources，2012，50(1). [7] Tepper B J，Henle C A，Lambert L S，et al.Abusive supervision and subordinates' organization deviance[J].Journal of Applied Psychology，2008，93(4). [8] Zellars K L，Tepper B J，Duffy M K.Abusive supervision and subordinates' organizational citizenship behavior[J].Journal of Applied Psychology，2002，87(6). [9] Chi S C S，Liang S G.When do subordinates' emotion-regulation strategies matter? Abusive supervision，subordinates' emotional exhaustion，and work withdrawal[J].The Leadership Quarterly，2013，24(1). [10] 李宁琪，易小年.组织公平，辱虐管理及员工工作倦怠关系实证研究[J].科技与管理，2010(4). [11] Aryee S，Chen Z X，Sun L Y，et al.Antecedents and outcomes of abusive supervision：test of a trickle-down model[J].Journal of Applied Psychology，2007，92(1). [12] Ma H，Karri R，Chittipeddi K.The paradox of managerial tyranny[J].Business Horizons，2004，47(4). [13] 杨东，吴晓蓉.疏离感研究的进展及理论构建[J].心理科学进展，2002(1). [14] Nasurdin A M，Ramayah T，Kumaresan S.Organisational stressors and job stress among managers：The moderating role of neuroticism[J].Singapore Management Review，2005，27(2). [15] Jesús Surez-Mendoza M，Zoghbi-Manrique-de-Lara P.The impact of work alienation on organizational citizenship behavior in the Canary Islands[J].International Journal of Organizational Analysis，2008，15(1). [16] Lodahl T M，Kejnar M.The definition and measurement of job involvement[J].Journal of applied psychology，1965，49(1). [17] 林琳，时勘，萧爱铃.工作投入研究现状与展望[J].管理评论，2008(3). [18] Schaufeli W B，Salanova M，González-Romá V，et al.The measurement of engagement and burnout：A two sample confirmatory factor analytic approach[J].Journal of Happiness studies，2002，3(1). [19] 罗红卫.心理报酬与员工工作投入度关系的实证研究[J].企业经济，2012（1）. [20] 胡三嫚，刘明前.工作不安全感及其对工作投入度与生活满意感的影响[J].中国健康心理学杂志，2011(1). [21] 吴隆增，刘军，刘刚.辱虐管理与员工表现：传统性与信任的作用[J].心理学报，2009(6). [22] Aryee S，Sun L Y，Chen Z X G，et al.Abusive supervision and contextual performance：The mediating role of emotional exhaustion and the moderating role of work unit structure[J].Management and Organization Review，2008，4(3). [23] 王洪青，彭纪生.辱虐管理对员工心态的影响：代际差异的调节效应研究[J].商业经济与管理，2015(1). [24] Tepper B J，Duffy M K，Shaw J D.Personality moderators of the relationship between abusive supervision and subordinates' resistance[J].Journal of Applied Psychology，2001，86(5). [25] 任晗，许亚玲，陈维政.代际差异视角下的辱虐管理对员工工作疏离感的影响作用[J].经济管理，2014(2). [26] 朱月龙，段锦云，凌斌.辱虐管理的概念界定与影响因素及结果探讨[J].外国经济与管理，2009(12). [27] Martinko M J，Harvey P，Brees J R，et al.A review of abusive supervision research[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior，2013，34(S1). [28] Tepper B J.Abusive supervision in work organizations：Review，synthesis，and research agenda[J].Journal of Management，2007，33(3). [29] 李爱梅，华涛，高文.辱虐管理研究的 “特征—过程—结果” 理论框架[J].心理科学进展，2013(11). [30] 李楠楠，陈伟娜，凌文辁.组织中的不当督导及相关研究[J].心理科学进展，2009(5). [31] 王汝津，滕峰丽.透视中国家族企业文化[J].经济管理，2005(15). [32] 戴万稳，谢碧明.如何预测职场冷暴力：辱虐管理行为诱因研究[J].管理学家(学术版)，2011（12）. [33] Eisenhardt K M.Building theories from case study research[J].Academy of management review，1989，14(4). [34] Brown S L，Eisenhardt K M.The art of continuous change：Linking complexity theory and time-paced evolution in relentlessly shifting organizations[J].Administrative science quarterly，1997：1-34. [35] Graebner M E，Eisenhardt K M.The seller's side of the story：Acquisition as courtship and governance as syndicate in entrepreneurial firms[J].Administrative Science Quarterly，2004，49(3). [36] Yin R K.Case study research：design and methods.Thousands Oaks[J].International Educational and Professional Publisher，1994. [37] Jick T D.Mixing qualitative and quantitative methods：Triangulation in action[J].Administrative science quarterly，1979，24(4). [38] Eisenhardt K M，Graebner M E.Theory building from cases：Opportunities and challenges[J].Academy of Management Journal，2007，50(1). [39] Banai M，Reisel W D，Probst T M.A managerial and personal/control model：predictions of work alienation and organizational commitment in Hungary[J].Journal of International Management，2004，10(3). [40] Seeman M.Empirical alienation studies：An overview[M]//Theories of alienation.Springer US，1976. [41] De Dreu C K W，Weingart L R，Kwon S.Influence of social motives on integrative negotiation：a meta-analytic review and test of two theories[J].Journal of personality and social psychology，2000，78(5). [42] 林声洙，杨百寅.家长式领导对员工工作满意度的影响：组织支持感的中介作用[J].现代管理科学，2013(2). [43] 刘焕青.大学生领悟社会支持与负性情绪的研究[J].社会心理科学，2012(11). [44] Jeung C W.The concept of employee engagement：A comprehensive review from a positive organizational behavior perspective[J].Performance Improvement Quarterly，2011，24(2). [45] 刘晖，孙耀耀.国有企业辱虐管理对员工工作投入的作用机制研究[J].对外经贸，2016(1). [46] 胡少楠，王詠.工作投入的概念、测量、前因与后效[J].心理科学进展，2014(12). [47] Kahn W A.Psychological conditions of personal engagement and disengagement at work[J].Academy of management journal，1990，33(4). [48] Saks A M.Antecedents and consequences of employee engagement[J].Journal of managerial psychology，2006，21(7). [49] Kataria A，Garg P，Rastogi R.Psychological climate and organizational effectiveness：Role of work engagement[J].IUP Journal of Organizational Behavior，2013，12(3). [50] Parker S K，Axtell C M.Seeing another viewpoint：Antecedents and outcomes of employee perspective taking[J].Academy of Management Journal，2001，44(6). [51] 魏钧，张勉，杨百寅.组织认同受传统文化影响吗——中国员工认同感知途径分析[J].中国工业经济，2008(6). [52] Grant A M.Relational job design and the motivation to make a prosocial difference[J].Academy of Management Review，2007，32(2). [53] 张喆，贾明.下属逢迎行为何时有用? 亲社会动机和同理心的影响作用研究[J].管理工程学报，2016(1). [54] Leider S，Mbius M M，Rosenblat T，et al.Directed altruism and enforced reciprocity in social networks[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economics，2009. [55] Bear S E，Hwang A.Who mentors? Contextual prosocial motivation and willingness to be a mentor[J].Human Resource Development International，2015，18(1). [56] Grant A M，Berg J M.Prosocial motivation at work[Z].DOI：10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199734610.013.0003，2012. [57] Ashforth B E，Mael F.Social identity theory and the organization[J].Academy of management review，1989，14(1). [58] 李锐.职场排斥对员工职外绩效的影响：组织认同和工作投入的中介效应[J].管理科学，2010(3). [59] Cheney G，Christensen L T.Public relations as contested terrain[M]∥Handbook of public relations.Sage Publications，Incorporated，2001. [60] Brass L F.Issues in the development of thrombin receptor antagonists[J].Thrombosis and haemostasis，1995，74(1). [61] Smidts A，Pruyn A T H，Van Riel C B M.The impact of employee communication and perceived external prestige on organizational identification[J].Academy of Management journal，2001，44(5). [62] Ravasi D，Schultz M.Responding to organizational identity threats：Exploring the role of organizational culture[J].Academy of management journal，2006，49(3). [63] Glisson C，James L R.The cross-level effects of culture and climate in human service teams[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior，2002，23(6). [64] Karakowsky L，Siegel J P.The effect of demographic diversity on causal attributions of work group success and failure[M]//Attribution theory：An organizational perspective，1995. [65] Caruso E，Epley N，Bazerman M H.The costs and benefits of undoing egocentric responsibility assessments in groups[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology，2006，91(5). [66] Regan D T，Totten J.Empathy and attribution：turning observers into actors[J].Journal of Personality and social Psychology，1975，32(5). [67] Rabinowitz S，Hall D T.Organizational research on job involvement[J].Psychological bulletin，1977，84(2). [68] Cuyper N D，Mauno S，Kinnunen U，et al.Autonomy and Workload in Relation to Temporary and Permanent Workers' Job Involvement：A Test in Belgium and Finland[J].Journal of Personnel Psychology，2010，9(1). [69] 袁庆宏，丁刚，李珲.知识型员工职业成长与离职意愿——组织认同和专业认同的调节作用[J].科学学与科学技术管理，2014(1). [70] 杨永康，李艳霞.组织认同感与离职倾向关系研究[J].上海管理科学，2008(3).