吉首大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2006, Vol. 27 ›› Issue (6): 50-58.

• 历史学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

论王夫之法律思想中的近代性因素

  

  1. (南京大学 中国思想家研究中心,南京 210093)
  • 出版日期:2006-11-15 发布日期:2012-06-20
  • 作者简介:许苏民(1957-),江苏如皋人,南京大学中国思想家研究中心教授,博士生导师。
  • 基金资助:

    江苏省哲学社会科学研究基金项目(04LSA001)

The Elements of Modern Ideology in Wang Fuzhi's Law Ideas

  1. (Research Center of Chinese Thinkers,Nanjing University,Nanjing jiangsu,China)
  • Online:2006-11-15 Published:2012-06-20

摘要:中国传统思想的近代转型,始于明清之际。王夫之的法律思想,就从多方面突破了专制主义特权人治传统的局限,具有十分明显的近代性因素。他批判了孔子专门针对民众而言的“宽猛相济”的主张和“礼不下庶人,刑不上大夫”的特权人治原则,针锋相对地提出了“严以治吏”的观点和“刑尤详于贵,礼必逮于下”的法律原则,体现了现代法治国家重在防止官员犯罪的立法精神;他反对程颐、朱熹、张载等人以“道德”的名义恢复上古肉刑的主张,力主废除以非人道的方式对待罪犯的专制酷刑,反对把道学家的个人意气和民众的非理性的仇恨情绪置于法律之上,体现了现代国家法律至上的精神和人道主义的精神。他甚至还主张从国家的根本大法上“置天子于有无之外”,并主张以法律来制约君主的权力和制裁君主的不法行为,以建立一个“自天子始而天下咸受裁焉”的法治社会。如此等等,都反映了中国传统社会和思想文化向着近代转型的新的历史动向。

关键词: 王夫之, 法律思想, 近代性, 因素

Abstract: The shift of Chinese traditional ideas began in Ming and Qing Dynasty.Wang Fuzhi's thought on law is obvious of elements of modern ideology breaking through the limitations of the traditional autocracy and authority-rule.He criticized Confucian’s idea of “couple leniency with cruelty” and the principle of “no courtesy to the humble and no penalty to the officials” and diametrically put forward his idea of “strict with the officials” and his proposition of the rule “courteous to the humble and penal to the officials” embodying the legislative idea of emphasizing the precaution of crime by officials in modern law-ruled countries.Wang Fuzhi opposed the view of renewing the corporal punishment in the ancient times in the name of “morality” advocated by Cheng Yi,Zhu Xi and Zhang Zai.He advocated prohibiting the autocratic severe punishment to the criminals by treating them inhumanly and opposed the action laying more importance to the personal will of Confucian moralists and unreasonable hatred mood of the public than to the law,which is the symbol of humanism spirit and absolute power of law in modern countries.Wang even maintained that when drawing up the fundamental law of a country the King was only an ordinary person with no authority,whose power should be restrained and illegal act should be punished with laws,in order to establish a law-ruled society.All these views and propositions reflect the new history trend of Chinese traditional society and ideology transforming to the modern era.

Key words: Wang Fuzhi, law ideas, modernization, element

版权所有 © 2021《吉首大学学报(社会科学版)》编辑部
技术支持:北京玛格泰克科技发展有限公司
公众号 电子书橱 超星期刊 手机浏览 在线QQ